Forget Spirit Halloween. The best way to decorate and dress for the spooky season — or year-round, if that’s your style — is by shopping local.

Here are nine talented Indianapolis artists whose unique wares will get you in the mood for a macabre, monstrous and magical October.


Samuel Penaloza

@arte.de.sammy

Self-taught artist Samuel Penaloza recently had a solo exhibit at the Harrison Center titled “Black Sheep,” which explored “the darkness of the human experience” and how art can help us overcome our inner turmoil. His pieces are mostly acrylic on canvas, and many feature deconstruction of the human form as a focal point.

“Use Up,” 2024, by Samuel Penaloza. Credit: Samuel Penaloza
“Satori,” 2024, by Samuel Penaloza. Credit: Samuel Penaloza

Where to buy: You can find Samuel’s work currently on display at the Harrison Center, or you can buy pieces online for local pickup or shipping.


Gina Jo

@ginajoart

It’s no surprise Gina Joanne Cebulski has cultivated a massive online following. From watercolor and ink art pieces to handcrafted candles in skull and pumpkin jars, every one of her creations will feel like a magical addition to your home.

“Little Bat” by Gina Jo. Credit: Gina Jo

Where to buy: You can find Gina Jo’s art at local markets or on her Etsy shop.


AeroSoul Studio

@aerosoulpro

Stencil artist Brian Aldridge works with spray paint to recreate pop culture icons and monsters, like Elvira and Freddy Krueger, on wood or vinyl canvases. When he’s not in the art studio, he’s hosting the Electric Monster podcast, on which he discusses horror and cult classic films with guests.

AeroSoul Studio makes stickers, posters and other merch. Credit: AeroSoul Studio

Where to buy: You can find Aldridge’s pieces on his online shop or at local markets, like World Oddities Expo on Saturday, Nov. 8, at the Indiana State Fairgrounds.


Indy Moon Child

@indy_moon_child

If you liked the new music video for Lady Gaga’s “The Dead Dance,” you’ll love Indy Moon Child. Artist Deanne Parmer specializes in customizing creepy, one-of-a-kind babydoll heads. For those looking for something a little less nightmarish, she also creates fake potted flowers with eyeball florets.

Creepy porcelain doll heads and plants are part of Indy Moon Child’s style. Credit: Indy Moon Child

Where to buy: You can find Indy Moon Child at local markets, including the Historic Irvington Halloween Festival on Saturday, Oct. 25.


Pudding Overlord

@puddingoverlord

Pudding Overlord, aka Megan Fisher, is a freelance digital illustrator and teacher. Her pieces often blend creepy with cute, like her pulp horror pinup collection.

Creepy with cute is what Pudding Overlord goes for in their stickers and illustrations. Credit: Pudding Overlord

Where to buy: You can find Fisher’s art at local markets or buy pieces anytime from her online shop.


Cassie’s Curious Creations

@cassiescuriouscreations

From ballerina beetles to pastel dreamcatchers featuring tiny animal skulls, Cassie Kwitny makes decor pieces that any pastel goth is sure to love. The maker also offers custom designs and commissions to help you bring your sweetest (or scariest) nightmares to life.

Cassie’s Curious Creations are like sugar-covered nightmares. Credit: Cassie’s Curious Creations

Where to buy: You can find Cassie’s Curious Creations at local markets, including Big Gay Halloween Market Oct. 11-12 at the AMP at 16 Tech.


Amanda Marie Bell

@amandamariebell

Amanda Marie Bell is an art director, graphic designer and illustrator from Texas who now calls Indy home. Their bold prints are instantly recognizable thanks to a signature color palette and spooky tone they apply across all of their work.

“One Eye Open” by Amanda Marie Bell. Credit: Amanda Marie Bell

Where to buy: You can find Bell’s pieces on their online shop or Patreon, where members get monthly exclusive, limited-run prints and stickers.


Above and Below Oddities

@aboveandbelowoddities

Bring a little memento mori into your home decor with maker Shannon Carbajal’s preserved insects, delicately arranged in ornate frames. Carbajal also creates terrariums with skulls of animals like deer and coyotes.

Shannon Carbajal’s preserved insects see beauty in death. Credit: Above and Below Oddities

Where to buy: You can find Above and Below Oddities’ creations at The Source Indy, Hampton & Co., BaZaar Oh! Vintage and Harlot Apothecary.


Devere Cloth N Bone

@devereclothnbone

Gift a loved one (or yourself) a one-of-a-kind, handcrafted piece of jewelry made from ethically sourced bones. Maker Pearl Devere also creates mini framed art pieces featuring bones and real spiderwebs.

Devere Cloth ‘N Bone makes jewelry from ethically-sourced bones. Credit: Devere Cloth ‘N Bone

Where to buy: You can find Devere Cloth N Bone’s work at local markets. Keep an eye on their Instagram page for show announcements.


Creative Commons License

Republish our articles for free, online or in print, under a Creative Commons license.

Local news delivered straight to your inbox

Mirror Indy's free newsletters are your daily dose of community-focused news stories.

By clicking Sign Up, you’re confirming that you agree with our Terms of Use.

Related Articles