For Herman “Butch” Slaughter, Indiana Avenue is home.
He grew up in the historic neighborhood in the 1950s and ‘60s and attended Crispus Attucks his first year of high school. He remembers wandering the Avenue and seeing movies for 10 cents at what’s now the Madam Walker Legacy Center.
“This used to be where you heard music,” Slaughter said. “This used to be where you came to have a good time.”
Slaughter’s family moved in the early 1960s, anticipating changes to the area with the construction of the I-65 and I-70 interstates. But over the years, Slaughter maintained his connection to Indiana Avenue.
That’s why he attended a Nov. 17 open house where officials from the city’s Department of Metropolitan Development unveiled a strategic plan to redevelop and revitalize Indiana Avenue — an effort nearly four years in the making.
A century ago, Indiana Avenue was the center of Black culture and commerce in Indianapolis. The street was a hub for Black-owned businesses and its many jazz clubs hosted performers such as Duke Ellington, Ella Fitzgerald and local jazz guitarist Wes Montgomery.
But the construction of the interstates and the IUPUI campus in the 1960s and ‘70s displaced thousands of residents. Homes and businesses were razed to become university buildings and parking lots, and the Avenue fell into disrepair.
Now, decades later, the city’s plan reimagines Indiana Avenue with input from the community.
The plans to redevelop the historic corridor were first announced in February 2023 and the city held a public kickoff for the plan in April 2024. But staff turnover led to delays in finishing the plans, Department of Metropolitan Development Deputy Director Carmen Lethig said.
In that time, the city also switched from New York-based architecture firm Elizabeth Kennedy Landscape Architect to Ohio-based MKSK, which has an Indianapolis office.
“We evaluated where the plan needed to go, and in order for it to be actionable, it had to have some more local perspective,” Lethig said.
While Elizabeth Kennedy Landscape Architect led the initial listening and engagement sessions, MKSK incorporated community priorities and feedback into a plan of action.
Now, a draft of the city’s strategic plan is complete. The 139-page document includes recommendations for economic development, improved pedestrian access and public art and storytelling that honors Indiana Avenue’s vibrant history.
Nikeshia Fomby, administrator of engagement for the Department of Metropolitan Development, said that the city wants to create a place where people can feel like they belong.
“I want people to feel included, and I think that the plan speaks to inclusion,” Fomby said. “I think the overall feel should be a welcoming, open environment where people feel like they are still ingrained in the society of Indiana Avenue.”
What the plan says
The draft plan includes proposals based on recommendations by members of a work circle made up of neighbors, historians, planners and representatives from community organizations and nearby organizations, including both Purdue in Indianapolis and IU Indianapolis, Lethig said.
Proposals in the plan include extending the Cultural Trail southeast along Capitol Avenue and Washington Street and collaborating with the Trail to create public art and storytelling. The plan also proposes finding a way to use the city-owned site of the former Cancer Survivors Park at 10th Street and Indiana Avenue to honor Indiana Avenue’s cultural legacy.
As far as redevelopment goes, the city proposes preserving and redeveloping the former Colored Knights of Pythias building located at 711 N. Senate Ave. The historic structure, also called Castle Hall, was included on Indiana Landmarks’ list of the 10 most endangered buildings in Indiana this year.
The plan also proposes creating opportunities for Black-owned businesses in the Indiana Avenue area and establishing scholarships and workforce development opportunities for residents who live in surrounding neighborhoods.
“It just was a general sentiment that we heard throughout the planning process,” Lethig said, “that as part of whatever redevelopment happens along the Avenue, there should be a benefit for the Black community.”
For Steve Nelson, a resident of the Ransom Place neighborhood, Indiana Avenue is practically in his backyard.
At the Nov. 17 event, Nelson said he especially supports some of the ideas to bring more businesses and economic reinvestment in the area.
“I think it’d be very helpful to bring another positive light onto this part of the city,” Nelson, 50, told Mirror Indy.
As for Slaughter, he’s maintained his connection to the Avenue. For years, he shared the Avenue’s jazz roots and musical history with a new generation as the co-host of Echoes of Indiana Avenue on WFYI.
Music from his group, Words of Wisdom, plays on the Avenue as part of the Cultural Trail’s Indiana Avenue Sound Experience.
Slaughter hopes that the city and its partners prioritize music and the arts as part of what’s next for the Avenue. He’d love to see a music academy in the plans, or even a club to honor the area’s jazz roots.
“You got a building here. If this space is not available, make one available,” Slaughter said. “It’s that important.”
What’s next?
The plan recommends hiring a full-time staff person to oversee the Indiana Avenue redevelopment efforts.
That staff person likely will not be a city employee, Lethig said, so the city is working with its partners to figure out a plan for how and where that person will work.
The Department of Metropolitan Development also wants to certify the plan by early next year. By March 2027, the city also aims to create a public-facing dashboard where community members can track the status of the project.
Give feedback
If you couldn’t make it to the open house, you can still learn about the plan and share your thoughts.
You can leave comments on Konveio, the city’s website for strategic plans. You’ll need to create a free account to leave comments. The draft plan can be found at this link, and there are two parts.
You can switch from the first to the second part of the plan using the bar at the bottom of the page.
People have until Dec. 18 to leave comments, Lethig said.
Mirror Indy, a nonprofit newsroom, is funded through grants and donations from individuals, foundations and organizations.
Claire Rafford covers higher education for Mirror Indy in partnership with Open Campus. Contact Claire by email claire.rafford@mirrorindy.org, at 317-759-0249 or on most social media @clairerafford.




