After months of back and forth, it appears the 113-year-old Catholic church building on the former Martin University campus will not be demolished.
Trena Roudebush, a spokesperson for the Department of Metropolitan Development, told Mirror Indy that the city and the building’s owner, Eastern Star Church, have reached an agreement that the former St. Francis de Sales Church building will be preserved.
In fact, Eastern Star is now planning to sell the former St. Francis de Sales Church building, Roudebush said. According to reporting from IndyStar, Eastern Star’s attorney Howard Stevenson said a buyer has shown interest, but he declined to name them.

Martin University closed at the end of 2025. Eastern Star Church purchased the former campus in May and renamed it the ROCK Impact Center, an expansion of its existing Renewing Our Community for the Kingdom Initiative.
The pivot to sell the property comes after a contractor filed a wrecking permit to demolish the former St. Francis de Sales Catholic Church on Martin’s campus in August. In response, the Indianapolis Historic Preservation Commission voted to grant historic status to the church building.
That put the demolition on hold, though any historic recognition for the property still has to be approved by the Metropolitan Development Commission.
Neither Stevenson nor Pastor Anthony Murdock, who leads the ROCK Initiative at Eastern Star Church, responded to Mirror Indy’s questions.
Preserving history
St. Francis de Sales Catholic Church was established in 1881 and its current building was constructed in 1913.

For over a century, the church and an attached Catholic school served eastside families. It closed in 1983, largely because of declining membership caused by the construction of the I-70 interstate, according to the Archdiocese of Indianapolis.
Because of Martin University’s status as the only predominantly Black university in Indianapolis, Indiana Landmarks has had the campus on its radar for preservation, said André Myers, the new director of the Indiana Landmarks’ Black Heritage Preservation Program.
“When Eastern Star purchased the property, we saw that as an opportunity to help be part of the conversation on retaining these properties,” Myers told Mirror Indy, “helping them have a viable and vibrant future, adding to the surrounding community.”
Earlier this year, Indiana Landmarks awarded a $25,000 grant to fund an assessment of the building’s conditions. Myers said the assessment found that the building is in good enough condition to be preserved and not at immediate risk of collapse.

“Just like any old building, it needs some love, it needs some attention,” Myers said, “but it is solid.”
The assessment is now complete and in Eastern Star’s hands, Myers said.
The Metropolitan Development Commission was scheduled to vote on a historic area plan for the property Nov. 18, but both the city and Eastern Star requested the vote be continued until Jan. 6, 2027.
In September, Murdock told Mirror Indy that Eastern Star staff did not know the church would be considered historic and that if they did, they would’ve thought twice about acquiring it.
Murdock also said that Eastern Star was “open to those discussions” about possibly selling the historic church building.
“We just don’t have experience developing historic spaces,” Murdock said, “and what we’ve learned is that we want to do what we do very well, and then those things we don’t do well, others can do.”
Mirror Indy, a nonprofit newsroom, is funded through grants and donations from individuals, foundations and organizations.
Claire Rafford covers higher education for Mirror Indy in partnership with Open Campus. Contact Claire by email claire.rafford@mirrorindy.org, at 317-759-0249 or on most social media @clairerafford.




