Sister Marie Racine was a software engineer in Massachusetts for 17 years, but she felt something was missing. Racine started discerning — praying intently — in the late 1990s to better understand what she should do next.

“I thought God was disrupting my wonderful life,” Racine joked. “And then I couldn’t resist the call.”

Racine found the sisters of St. Benedict’s Our Lady of Grace Monastery online after searching for a live-in community that prayed at least twice a day and had opportunities for ministry. She visited in October 1999 and moved to the monastery the following year.

Sister Marie Racine sits in her room, looking toward Sister Mary Luke Jones, not pictured, Nov. 4, 2026, at Our Lady of Grace Monastery in Beech Grove, Ind. Credit: Stephanie Amador for Mirror Indy

She turned 40 years old the day after she moved in.

“And you know that saying, ‘Life begins at 40,’” she said. “That’s what it felt like for me. It’s a great life.” For Racine, it’s been “a love story with Christ.”

Our Lady of Grace Monastery, 1402 Southern Ave., has been in Beech Grove for 71 years. Monasteries are a home for religious devotees, such as nuns and monks, who dedicate their lives to prayer and contemplation. The southside holy grounds specifically support women.

But many things have changed over the long years. Outdated facilities and decline in sisters led them to move into a new, smaller facility this year.

As Indianapolis’ only monastery of women, the sisters have served residents through prayer, education, healthcare, community and private events. Some of those offerings are still provided, while the school and nursing home no longer exist. The original building also became outdated over time, full of asbestos and lacking central air conditioning and other modern amenities.

Renovating the building would have been too expensive. And maybe it was time to downsize anyway.

From left, sisters Margaret Ann Dailey, Helen Vermeulen, Karen Byerley and Lucia Betz have lunch together Nov. 4, 2026, at Our Lady of Grace Monastery in Beech Grove, Ind. Credit: Stephanie Amador for Mirror Indy

The Benedictine sisters love their life, but they’ve struggled to attract women. Our Lady of Grace Monastery was once home to roughly 160 sisters.

Now, there’s 40. Times have changed in a couple generations, as many women have families or work full-time jobs, leading companies or even running for president.

“Women have been able to do different things, and greater things,” Sister Mary Luke Jones said. “I tell everybody, it’s a great life, but it’s not as appealing as it was back in the ‘50s, for example.”

71 years on the south side

The sisters of St. Benedict first immigrated from Europe to the United States in the 1840s, settling in Pennsylvania. As women outgrew their congregations, they expanded across the country, including Erie, Pennsylvania; Covington, Kentucky and Ferdinand in southwest Indiana before they eventually built a facility in Beech Grove.

Some of the founding Benedictine sisters of Our Lady of Grace Monastery breaking ground on the Beech Grove facility in the 1950s. Credit: Provided photo/Our Lady of Grace Monastery

Swampland was transformed into Our Lady of Grace Monastery in 1955, according to a stone engraving on the side of the building that was transferred from the old facility. They also had an academy until it closed in 1978 due to declining enrollment, according to the sisters’ website. After closing the academy, the sisters turned a section of the building into a retreat space for local community groups, businesses and schools.

Beech Grove Mayor Jim Coffman remembers visiting the monastery for his senior retreat in high school. He’s glad the sisters will continue to reside on the south side.

“The sisters who are here dedicate their lives to helping others, not just in the city of Beech Grove, but in the greater region,” Coffman said. “We’re thankful to have them here. They support our city, they support our residents and they’re a huge part of our history, and also a huge part of our future.”

Jones, who’s been with the monastery for 60 years, still remembers the old building.

“When I entered, we lived in dormitories,” she said, “We didn’t really even have a room. We had a great big room that had partitions that didn’t even go up to the ceiling or down to the floor.”

Sister Mary Luke Jones poses inside the chapel Nov. 4, 2026, at Our Lady of Grace Monastery in Beech Grove, Ind. Credit: Stephanie Amador for Mirror Indy

The sisters also founded St. Paul Hermitage Retirement and Nursing Care in 1997. Kathy Hartman got to know the sisters when she would visit her uncle at the nursing home.

“It was just a wonderful place if you had to be at a nursing home or assisted living facility,” Hartman said. “The people were just very nice here and caring.”

The assisted living facility was a separate building from the monastery and remains, but under a different name and owners: Envive Healthcare of Beech Grove.

The nuns sold the healthcare facility in 2022, partially because of the decline in sisters, quickly changing medical policies during the COVID-19 pandemic and the financial feasibility of a standalone clinic.

“These days, in the nursing home industry, you can’t own just one,” Sister Julie Sewell said. “You really have to own more of them to be able to really financially make it work. So we could kind of see the writing on the wall down the road.”

The sisters used existing funds, the profit from selling the clinic and raised about $7 million to create the new building. The old monastery was demolished to create a parking lot and allow for more trees.

The former Our Lady of Grace Monastery being demolished on the south side of Marion County in Beech Grove. Credit: Provided photo/Our Lady of Grace Monastery

Connie Lund, president of the monastery’s lay board of advisors made up of community members who provide advice on matters, including on finances and space.

She always feels better after visiting the monastery. Lund said she enjoys supporting the sisters and their work.

“They’re an anchor of stability in the area,” Lund said. “They live a life of generosity and kindness and we should all strive to be more like them.”

A new chapter

The sisters have held open houses over the past few months to allow the community to see their new monastery.

The new facility has multiple spaces, including a gym, music room and a hair salon. Visitors will still see familiar items, including artwork, sculptures and organ pipes that were transferred from the old building.

“It’s nice to see them here,” said Vivian Bailey, a friend of the nuns. “It feels like home again.”

All 36 rooms are occupied.

Behind the new building is a circular cemetery with stations of the Christ, wooden engravings depicting Jesus’ life. Jones said about 95 sisters have been buried, including two who passed since they moved into the new building earlier this year.

At the end of a funeral service’s mass, the sister is taken outside to the cemetery. Her body is carried through the chapel’s left side doorway, which is surrounded by metalwork outlines of leaves and flowers, designed to represent life and death.

Residents say the new monastery is decorated with symbols from the past, while the new building looks ahead to what’s to come.

Sister Lucia Betz walks out of the chapel after having midday prayer Nov. 4, 2026, at Our Lady of Grace Monastery in Beech Grove, Ind. Credit: Stephanie Amador for Mirror Indy
The cemetery holds sisters’ tombstones on Nov. 4, 2026, at Our Lady of Grace Monastery in Beech Grove, Ind. Credit: Stephanie Amador for Mirror Indy
if you go

Mass is open to the public at 5:15 p.m. Wednesdays and 11a.m. Sundays at Our Lady of Grace Monastery, 1402 Southern Ave.

Mirror Indy, a nonprofit newsroom, is funded through grants and donations from individuals, foundations and organizations. Sign up for our free newsletters.

Mirror Indy reporter Elizabeth Gabriel covers the south side of Marion County. Contact her at elizabeth.gabriel@mirrorindy.org. Follow her on X at @_elizabethgabs.

Creative Commons License

Republish our articles for free, online or in print, under a Creative Commons license.

Local news delivered straight to your inbox

Mirror Indy's free newsletters are your daily dose of community-focused news stories.

By clicking Sign Up, you’re confirming that you agree with our Terms of Use.

Related Articles